Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Scotland Explained's avatar

Encouraging to see the focus shift from waiting on one party to building durable civic capacity across the movement. The crucial test will be governance: transparent finance, accountable leadership, genuine autonomy for member groups and room for disagreement. If YES2030 embeds those principles from the start, it could begin building the civic infrastructure that statehood would require.

Stephen Duncan's avatar

A couple of thoughts:

"Vision: what a better nation looks like in all key areas"

Do we really need yet another 'vision'? The trouble with visions is that everybody has one! Ask every person in Scotland for theirs and you'll get around 5.4m unique ones in response.

Visions don't increase support for Independence. On the contrary they create division. Efforts should be concentrated on HOW we exercise our right of self-determination and ultimately progress once more to independent statehood.

"Strengthen support for independence up to and beyond 55%"

We should be careful about setting thresholds for 'support'. How do you measure it? If you propose opinion polls as the barometer, which one(s)? And over what period of time?

I think that you would be creating a hostage to fortune by setting any kind of bar.

Far better to a) establish a practical path to full self-government and then b) run a campaign on the merits of nation statehood (running your own affairs according your own priorities and values) versus the demerits of union/annexation (letting an unrepresentative foreign parliament make decisions for you).

No posts

Ready for more?