What evidence does Alex Neil have for claiming that Westminster will say “get on with it” if independence sentiment reaches 60%?
When he says that Westminster won’t be able to say ‘No’ because “the Scottish people not let them” my question to Alex Neil is “How?” What would make Westminster fold as easily as Alex Neil asserts would happen?
Is it not just as likely that if support for Independence climbs to the magic 60% threshold that Westminster will merely say there needs to be 67% or 75% or 90% support before they will yield?
The premise in Alex Neil’s speech is that Westminster has the final say. If Westminster is granted a veto on Scottish self-determination they are likely to use it. Always and under all circumstances. Why wouldn’t they?
In any event how would you measure it?
Would this be an average? A maximum? A minimum? The mode or median?
Over what period of time?
Which pollsters surveys would be employed?
It’s all terribly arbitrary and open to interpretation.
Worse it places Westminster above the Scottish people.
Hi Alf, I am sure your speech does merit a specific video cut, because you always make a lot of sense and speak very well, but I am just posting what SSRG has on their Youtube channel and so far they haven't done a separate cut with your speech on it as far as I am aware?
What evidence does Alex Neil have for claiming that Westminster will say “get on with it” if independence sentiment reaches 60%?
When he says that Westminster won’t be able to say ‘No’ because “the Scottish people not let them” my question to Alex Neil is “How?” What would make Westminster fold as easily as Alex Neil asserts would happen?
Is it not just as likely that if support for Independence climbs to the magic 60% threshold that Westminster will merely say there needs to be 67% or 75% or 90% support before they will yield?
The premise in Alex Neil’s speech is that Westminster has the final say. If Westminster is granted a veto on Scottish self-determination they are likely to use it. Always and under all circumstances. Why wouldn’t they?
In any event how would you measure it?
Would this be an average? A maximum? A minimum? The mode or median?
Over what period of time?
Which pollsters surveys would be employed?
It’s all terribly arbitrary and open to interpretation.
Worse it places Westminster above the Scottish people.
Just as John Swinney’s SNP does.
For some reason? you left out the 4th speech in that session, which was mine, from 2.23 to 2.35 here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p-BuEL5wLO0
Apologies Alf, just an oversight, I will add it in.
Appreciate the effort to correct, however it appears my speech does not merit a specific video cut, like the other 3?
Hi Alf, I am sure your speech does merit a specific video cut, because you always make a lot of sense and speak very well, but I am just posting what SSRG has on their Youtube channel and so far they haven't done a separate cut with your speech on it as far as I am aware?
Hi again Alf, I have updated the post a bit more. I wasn't aware that you were part of that session, my apologies.